How to Compare Contractor Bids for the Same Remodel
Compare contractor bids for the same remodel. Use a worked bathroom example to check materials, exclusions, allowances and costs before signing.
By LocalContractorBids Editorial Team
Published
Updated

One bathroom bid is $18,000. The other is $20,000. Both say “replace tub with shower,” so the $2,000 gap looks like an easy win. Then you notice that the first bid leaves the shower glass and disposal to you. The second includes both.
Before you pick a contractor, get the bids to describe the same job. Match the finished work, materials, allowances and exclusions. Ask for written prices on the differences you can resolve. Give the things you still can't price their own row.
Watch the $2,000 gap disappear
Here's a fictional comparison, using made-up numbers to show the method. You want the same glass panel and disposal in either proposal. After you ask, Contractor A sends a written revision: $1,650 for the specified glass and $650 for hauling and disposal. The revised scope now costs $20,300. Contractor B's $20,000 already covers those items.
| Comparison | Bid A | Bid B |
|---|---|---|
| Starting total | $18,000 | $20,000 |
| Specified glass panel and installation | $1,650 in written revision | Included |
| Hauling and disposal | $650 in written revision | Included |
| Total with those two items included | $20,300 | $20,000 |
| Subfloor condition | Price unknown until opened | Price unknown until opened |
A is now $300 higher on the work you've aligned. You still have a subfloor question, and neither revised total answers it. Ask both contractors what they will document if they find damage and how they'll price it before doing extra work. A made-up allowance in your spreadsheet doesn't settle the actual price.
That's the point of comparing scope first: you find out which prices mean something before spending time debating the gap.
Describe the bathroom you want to use
Give everyone one written project brief. In this example, the layout stays, the old tub comes out, the new shower gets a specified glass panel, and the contractor protects the hallway and removes debris. List the vanity and tile you have selected. Mark the things you still need to choose.
Write down how you expect each edge of the job to end. Will the old tub leave a patch in the floor? Who fixes the baseboard where it meets the new shower? Who reconnects the vanity plumbing? If two bidders make different assumptions, a photo and a sentence about the finished condition can save several phone calls.
Ask each contractor to identify decisions they cannot make until a site visit or demolition. Keep those apart from choices you can settle today, such as the tile model or who buys the fixtures.
Put every unclear line in one of four buckets
Use included, excluded, allowance or unconfirmed. An included item should say what it covers. An excluded item still needs someone to handle it. An allowance is an amount carried in the bid for something that isn't fully priced. Unconfirmed means you still need an answer.
For example, “tile $800” could mean material only, with delivery and installation handled elsewhere. A different bid could include delivery in the amount. Ask what the allowance covers, whether an overage includes markup and whether you get a credit if the actual purchase is lower. Our remodeling allowances guide walks through that calculation.
If you plan to buy the vanity yourself, ask who checks its dimensions, who handles a damaged delivery and what happens to the schedule if it arrives late. A lower contractor total can still leave you carrying more work.
Give the comparison a few rows beyond price
| Row | What you need in writing |
|---|---|
| Finish and materials | Model, finish, quantities, preparation and who purchases each item |
| Exclusions | Who will arrange and pay for every necessary item outside the bid |
| Permit and inspection | What the local authority requires, who handles it and whether the price includes fees |
| Schedule and access | Start assumptions, expected duration, access and when the room can be used |
| Payments | Amounts and the completed work or delivery that triggers them |
| Unknown conditions | How the contractor documents, prices and gets approval for extra work |
| Warranty | What is covered, for how long and who handles a claim |
The FTC's home improvement guidance recommends multiple written estimates that describe work, materials, timing and price. It also recommends asking about large differences instead of automatically taking the low bid. For licenses, check the relevant state or county office and ask for insurance evidence. Ask your local building department about permits and inspections for your actual project.
For payments, put the schedule beside the scope before you sign. “After installation” needs a shared definition of what is installed. The payment milestone guide shows how to match an invoice to that definition. Check local rules rather than assuming a deposit percentage or change procedure applies everywhere.
Send the two questions that change the decision
In the bathroom example, you could write:
“Please revise the price to include the specified glass panel, installation and all hauling and disposal. For subfloor damage found after demolition, please explain what you will show us, how you will price the repair and when we would approve the change.”
Start with the questions that can change who you hire. Put the answers in the revised proposal, then confirm the final agreement carries over the same scope, dates, assumptions and payment terms. A promise in a text message is easy to miss when you review a different document at signing.
If both totals are now comparable, look at who answered clearly and what each proposal expects you to manage. If one contractor can't explain a material difference, keep that row open. You don't have to turn an incomplete bid into a decision.
LocalContractorBids provides planning resources and links to contractor options. If you're ready to look for estimates, start from the LocalContractorBids homepage. Verify each contractor independently and read the final agreement before signing.